Aloo Anday for me is one of the curries that sometimes I don’t make for months at a time. It’s easy to slip by through the meals plans featuring meat and chicken, fish and more fancier rice dishes.
Aloo Anday is simple, basic and economic.
It reminds me of lazy afternoon lunches at home, or days when you’re completely hungover and in a food-induced coma and just need the simplest of the simple.
How To Make a Good Shorba
I spoke about this in my Matar Gosht post – making a good shorba has been a challenge for me in the past. A good shorba is smooth, no visible large chunks of tomato and onion, it is flavourful and is dyed a shade of brown-red. And according to my Mother, something that has really stuck by me over the years, a good shorba will have a rim of orange running around the sides of the curry.
In regards to a smooth shorba, this will require breaking down the onions and tomatoes completely, till they are melded into one jammy masala. This can be done by some hardcore bhun-ing at the masala frying stage – add a few splashes of water if you feel the masala isn’t smooth enough and continue stirring till the masala is smooth. If you don’t have the time or patience for this, then the food processor is your best friend. Blitz everything in the processor and you’ll have a perfect base ready in seconds.
Additionally, you have to keep an eye on the amount of onion and tomato in a shorba. You need far less than you’d think – I learn this the hard way! If you use too much, your shorba will be thick, possibly gloopy and not smooth and soup-like we want. I would find this SUCH a difficult concept to get my head around for some reason! Eventually, a rule of thumb I managed to figure out was – 1 medium onion and 2 small tomatoes is enough for plenty of shorba to serve 4 people.
Handling the Anday (eggs) in your Aloo Anday
I like to serve my eggs halved, added directly to my serving bowl so the side that is facing me remains clear and not marred with shorba. I prefer how this looks – the lighter whites/yellows of the egg look great against the darker browns/reds of the shorba.
When halving the eggs, I think it’s important to make sure you are halving directly through the centre of the yolk. Perhaps you’ll know from experience, when you blindly halve a boiled egg and you only get 1/4 of the yolk on one side and 3/4 on the other, the smaller portion of the yolk may fall out. Uhh, I don’t want bits of yolk floating around in my shorba, thanks!
To ensure you’re hitting the centre of the yolk, just take a close look at the boiled egg. You’ll be able to see a darker shade peeping through the whites – that’s of course the yolk. Cut through the centre of that – ta-da! Perfectly halved eggs for your viewing and consuming pleasure 🙂
If you don’t have the patience or time to halve your eggs and add them at the end just before serving, you can add your eggs whole directly into the shorba just before serving
Note on Oil Use
There’s no two ways around this. To get that proper traditional-looking shorba that mimics the shorba your Mother or Naani or Daadi made, you’ll have to use a lot of oil. That’s just the nature of these sorts of curries.
If too much oil makes you uncomfortable or it just isn’t your preference, you are very free to decrease the amount of oil stated. You will to some extent have to compromise on the end look of the shorba, but I can completely understand how excess oil may not sound too appealing if it’s not what you’re used to.
On the flipside, if you find the amount of oil stated isn’t giving you the look and feel you desire or are used to, you can add additional oil. You can add the oil at the end if you so wish, just make sure you give the oil to heat up and meld into the shorba.
OK, those are a lot of tips and information! They’re really handy for other shorba recipes and meals too which you may want to delve into.
Without further ado, here’s my very simple, very easy and VERY tasty Aloo Anday recipe!
Enjoy, with love x
Aloo Anday Ka Salan | Aloo Anda Shorba | Egg and Potato Curry
A delicious, simple and traditional Pakistani lunch - this Aloo Anday recipe is a pure comfort food. Serve with plain white basmati rice
- 1/3 cup oil
- 1 medium onion, finely diced
- 3-4 cloves of garlic, chopped or minced
- 2 small tomatoes, chopped
- salt, to taste
- 1 tsp coriander powder
- 1 tsp chilli powder, or to taste
- 1 tsp cumin seeds
- 0.5 tsp turmeric powder
- 2 medium potatoes, chopped into equal sized chunks
- 3 eggs
- A small handful of chopped coriander
- Heat the oil in a pot. Once well heated, add the chopped onions. Stir continuously to avoid burning or uneven browning
- Once the onions are light gold, add the garlic and cumin seeds. Stir these in for a few moments
- Add the chopped tomatoes and all the remaining spices
- Saute the tomatoes and once they have broken down for the most part, add a splash of water, cover with a lid and turn the heat down to low
- Allow this to cook for a few minutes. Once most of the water has dried out, take off the lid.
- At this point, you can either blitz everything in a food processor or continue to add some more water and cook down the masala. By the end of this step, you want a smooth paste with minimal chunks of onion or tomato visible though.
- Once your masala is smooth and ready, add 1.5 cups of water and the potatoes. Cover with a lid and cook on low till the potatoes are tender
- Meanwhile, boil your eggs in a separate pot. 8 minutes was enough for me to get a slightly soft yolk as shown in the images. Halve once done (optional)
- Once your potatoes are tender, turn off the heat and stir in the coriander
- Once you are ready to serve, dish out the curry and place in the halved eggs yolk side up, Optionally, garnish the final piece with more chopped coriander
Wednesday 5th of October 2022
Great advice about how to make shorba. I learned the hard way not to use too much onion and tomato. Not many recipes actually go through the method to get shorba right or acknowledge how hard it is, so this is much appreciated! Another thing that helps. When bhunafying the Masala keep the heat high and wait until the oil separates, then turn it down as soon as you add the water to a very very low simmer. My heat was never adjusted to get that oil to rise to the top of a watery shorba.
Tuesday 7th of March 2023
Thank you so much, Rumi! And some great advice!
Monday 26th of September 2022
How much salt did you add yourself? I’m a beginner and also my Tastebuds don’t work much when it comes to salt lol
Khatte Aloo | Khattay Aloo | Tangy Potatoes - Fatima Cooks
Tuesday 8th of March 2022
[…] Aloo ki Bhujia | Achari Aloo | Aloo Anday | Aloo Baingan | Aloo […]
Tuesday 19th of May 2020
I tried this the other day Was so tasty and easy to make Family loved it with roti
Saturday 25th of July 2020
Aloo Anday ka Salan (Egg and Potato Shorba Curry) – foodvegetarian
Friday 24th of April 2020
[…] fatimacooks.net/… […]